Wall Street titans smiled and schmoozed at a Saudi investment conference widely shunned last year over a critic’s murder, but with wariness lingering some delegates kept their name cards discreetly out of sight.
Thousands of policy-makers and executives from over 30 countries packed into Riyadh’s Ritz-Carlton hotel, bedecked with frescoed ceilings and glittering chandeliers, for the three-day Future Investment Initiatve (FII) that opened Tuesday.
It was a striking contrast with last year’s summit, which was largely filled with delegates from Arab countries – many from Saudi Arabia itself – as the fallout over dissident journalist Jamal Khashoggi’s murder inside the Saudi consulate in Istanbul triggered mass cancellations by Western executives.
“Most notable are the people who came for the inaugural FII (in 2017), boycotted the second and now have returned for the third,” an American finance executive told AFP, declining to be named.
“It’s like they are giving their stamp of approval, saying to others: ‘It’s okay to come back to Saudi.'”
He referred specifically to American asset management company Blackrock’s chief executive Larry Fink and Stephen Schwarzman, head of private equity firm Blackstone, who participated in panels cheerleading Saudi reforms.
Others endorsing Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman included an all-star lineup of speakers, from Indian tycoon Mukesh Ambani to Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Brazil’s President Jair Bolsonaro.
But despite the ebullient mood on the stage, many delegates were squeamish about being named in media interviews, in a sign of the lingering reputational risk of doing business in Saudi Arabia.
Some sought to fly under the radar, flipping their name cards behind their coats or hiding them behind their ties. Some even appeared hesitant to share their business cards with journalists.
The Saudi organizers also sought to avoid media scrutiny, banning journalists with cameras from entering the main conference hall and from a gala dinner organised for delegates.
“The sanctions threat over Saudi’s human rights record is currently over, but reputational costs are ongoing,” Ryan Bohl, of the US geopolitical think tank Stratfor, told AFP.
“Most companies have made the judgement whether they will be affected or endure those costs. Those that don’t want those risks are staying away.”
Khashoggi’s murder plunged Saudi Arabia into a public relations crisis, forcing companies with ties to the kingdom to find a balance between their business considerations and maintaining their reputations.
Many of those attending this year are Wall Street financiers chasing a potential windfall from the upcoming stock market listing of state-owned oil giant Aramco, the world’s most profitable company.
“There is massive potential,” an executive from a Singapore-based manufacturer of engineering equipment told AFP.
“This is Saudi Arabia and Aramco – there is nothing bigger.”
But this year’s FII has few names from the world’s largest technology companies or from Hollywood, key areas of Saudi investment.
Global media companies, which in previous years sponsored the event and even moderated panels, are also absent.
But not everyone was squeamish – and especially not those scouting for deals.
“Reputational risk? No,” said Christian Giannini, of European tech investor 01 Ventures.
On the sidelines of FII, his company received a license from the Saudi Arabian General Investment Authority to establish a tech investment fund worth millions of dollars, Giannini told AFP.
KPMG, another consultancy with business ties to Saudi Arabia, is being represented at FII by around 25 executives, up from five last year, a company official told AFP.
The forum is billed as an economic coming-out party for the petro-state, which is seeking to diversify away from oil – and authorities are eager to project the kingdom’s economic ambitions.
Delegates were greeted with gizmos such as face recognition software used to welcome them by name as they walked into the palatial hotel.
A bevvy of talking robots and self-driving sweepers to clean the conference area were also on display.
“It’s better to help Saudis to build their future rather than sit back and do nothing and complain,” said Rudolph Waels, founder of consultancy Armalia Partners, who has attended all three FIIs.
“I have no hesitation to be here.”
The timing of the highly anticipated stock market debut of Aramco will be dictated by Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, the kingdom’s energy minister said Wednesday.
Aramco was expected to launch the first part of a two-stage IPO earlier in October, but the process has been delayed, reportedly due to the prince’s dissatisfaction with the valuation of the firm, which had been hoped to reach $2 trillion.
The long-awaited initial public offering will now happen on December 11 on the Riyadh stock market, Saudi-owned Al-Arabiya television said on Tuesday.
Aramco did not confirm the report and Energy Minister Prince Abdulaziz bin Salman side-stepped the details when he spoke at a major investment conference in Riyadh where the listing has been a topic of discussion.
“I hate this time around to disappoint the media, because I’m not going to talk about OPEC or what we should do, and I’m not going to talk about the IPO,” he said to laughs from the audience of policy-makers and top executives.
“It’s going to come soon … but it will come at the right time with the right approach, and definitely with the right decision. And it will be a Saudi decision first and foremost, specifically Prince Mohammed’s decision,” he added.
Prince Abdulaziz is the half-brother of the crown prince, whose ambitious reform plans for the kingdom’s economy largely rest on the anticipated $100 billion windfall from the Aramco listing.
After an initial listing on the domestic stock exchange, Aramco is believed to be planning to sell the rest of a planned tranche of five percent of the firm on an international bourse.
“The Saudis’ current objective is to raise $100 billion through the IPO process, even if that means ultimately selling up to 10 percent of the company to outside investors,” Energy Intelligence said in a report this week.
It cited sources as saying they expect the Saudis to settle on a valuation of $1.6 trillion to $1.7 trillion for the firm.